Home   Links   Editorials

If A = B and B = C, does A = C?

Bob Moriarty
Archives

May 4, 2016

A century ago when I was in high school, one of my teachers wanted to teach us the basics of logic. The teacher began with the simple equation of if A = B and B = C, does A = C? Of course the majority of the class picked the most obvious answer.

But what happens when the apparent answer is not the correct answer? What if the obvious is dead wrong?

Here is the proof. If an airplane is transportation and a train is transportation, is an airplane the same as a train? Now the correct answer is both apparent and obvious. No. A train and an airplane are both transportation but they are not the same.

As investors, why is this important for us to know? I answer that in my new best-selling Amazon book, Nobody Knows Anything. Any ordinary person using nothing more than common sense and what they already know or can easily obtain, can learn to make profitable decisions if only they learn to ignore the experts, the gurus and other fools.

Click image to enlarge

For example, if you knew that silver had climbed from $4.01 an ounce in November of 2001 to $49 and change in April of 2011 using nothing but your own common sense you could reasonably conclude that silver was cheap in 2001 relative to silver in 2011. And that it was expensive in 2011 relative to what it had been in 2001.

You didn’t need to know anything else to make an intelligent decision. If you did nothing more than buy silver when it was cheap and sell it when it got expensive, you could have made a lot of money. 1140% in fact. Nobody did, of course, because they were too busy listening to the experts.

One of the greatest experts in silver, Eric Sprott, started a silver ETF in 2010. He spent most of his time on the road telling people what a great investment silver was. He was so successful that those listening to his siren song were willing to pay a 25% premium for his paper silver ETF at the end of April 2011. All of the gurus were mumbling about how high silver was going to go. Silver was somehow moving from weak hands into strong hands.

The loudest voice in silver had been claiming since at least 2001 that silver would go up ten or twenty fold if the US ever got into another war since it was the most valuable war material. The US had half a dozen wars to choose from so silver had to take off and go even higher.

There was even a group that managed to convince people that while silver was going from $4 to $50 it was being suppressed. Now you have to wonder at the gullibility of some people. How many people are actually dumb enough to watch a commodity enter into one of the greatest bull markets in history and still maintain that it was being suppressed?

On the other hand, an ordinary person of average intelligence could access the bullish consensus on silver at the very top of silver on January 21, 1980 and know that it was 94%. If all you knew was that the bullish consensus is always the highest at market tops and the lowest at market bottoms you could have made a very profitable decision in late April of 2011. All you had to do was understand the basics of investing.

If the bullish consensus was 94% at the very top of the silver market in 1980 and the bullish consensus was 96% in April of 2011, no matter what the gurus or experts said, we were probably at a top. I cover that in Chapter 2 of Nobody Knows Anything where I talk about contrarian investing. You need to know it.

Everyone could have done that; they didn’t need to listen to anyone else. Yes, they would need access to information. You would have to be able to find out what the price of silver is and a price history. And you would need to follow one of the services tracking bullish consensus but all that information is at your fingertips now because of the internet.

You would need to know the basics of investing because none of the experts or gurus wants you to think. They want your money and the only way to do that is to keep you ignorant. So they take your money and tell you what you want to hear. (A lack of) money is the root of all evil.

It’s a very successful business plan; politicians have been using it for centuries. If you tell people what they want to hear, they will vote for you. That’s just as true in investing as it is in the voting booth.

I can give you another perfect example where the use of simple basic logic can help you make intelligent investing decisions instead of following the rest of the lemmings over the cliff. Recently Deutsche Bank admitted they had been manipulating the gold fix. They did it the same way High Frequency Traders clip cents off of every stock trade; they were front running their customers.

The various banks running the gold fix have to know how supply and demand meet at a specific point in time to determine what the fix should be. So if demand was high, the participants in the fix would set the price just slightly higher than supply and demand would dictate.

If demand was low, they set the price slightly lower that it should have been. Since all markets move both up and down to determine the “right” price, their manipulation was both up and down and didn’t last for long before supply and demand resumed, getting the price right.

If Deutsche Bank manipulated the gold fix and long-term price suppression is manipulation, is manipulation equal to suppression? No, of course not. Because while suppression is always manipulation, manipulation isn’t always suppression.

So when you read a financial guru talk about how Deutsche Bank admitting that they manipulated the fix really means gold was suppressed all the way from $252 to $1923, you can logically determine if you really want to be giving them your hard-earned money. Manipulation isn’t necessarily suppression and any commodity that goes from $252 to $1923 isn’t being suppressed.

The Next Big Thing in investing is probably going to be commodities. I talk about The Next Big Thing in Chapter 8 of Nobody Knows Anything.

All commodities had a peak in 2011, not only silver and gold. They suffered a terrible and costly bear market, not only silver and gold. They all hit bottom late in 2015 and early 2016. It’s just as true of sugar and coffee as it is of gold and silver. And while a lot of people still want to mumble about how gold is being suppressed, it is factual to say that platinum and oil went down a lot more. Nobody is claiming they were suppressed. You can use your common sense in investing. It is not only a good idea it is probably mandatory.

Click image to enlarge

Bloomberg Commodity Index

When the train finally arrives at the station loaded with bags of money just for you, you don’t want to get caught out at the airport.

Books on Amazon are now dynamic. I can add a chapter to Nobody Knows Anything in a day. If readers think I have missed something and have suggestions as to something that I should add, please send me an email.

All commodities including gold and silver are going to go up a lot. There will be a time when they get expensive. If you won’t sell when you have a profit, the only other alternative is that you sell at a loss. Investing is simple but not necessarily easy. Please remind yourself that it was the bulls who wouldn’t sell who lost money in 1980 and 2011. There will come a time to sell both gold and silver as they become The Last Big Thing.

Here are some comments on the book from readers.

From JT on April 27 Great little book. Easy to read and very interesting. Good advice and those who take it to heart will be financially rewarded… This is one of the best books ever written on investing and don't let the small size or price fool you. Mr. Moriarty has provided the uninitiated a gem worth many times the price.

From QH on April 29 This is a great read. The history and anecdotes are in stark contrast to other books one might find on investing. This book really enables one to find and trust one's own instinct and common sense. I can see why conventionalists might not like it...because it is right!

From Amazon Customer on May 2 Bob does a fantastic job explaining what makes sense and what is hot air in the investing world. This book was full of real time examples and also very useful tips and trading strategies. I received more than what I expected.

From Amazon Customer on April 28 This is a great book for anyone that wants to know how to make money in precious metals, miners, and the stock market in general. It is well worth the price and identifies some key characteristics of when markets are getting near tops or near bottoms for that matter. Moriarty dispels the notion that there are gurus that know more than we do. It is a quick read with very good concise chapters. Well worth the money and the time. It may not tell you what you want to hear, but it may tell you what you need to know.

Nobody Knows Anything is available on Amazon in either Kindle version for $3.99 or in paperback for $9.99

###

Bob Moriarty
President: 321gold
Archives

321gold Ltd

Copyright ©2001-2017 321gold Ltd. All Rights Reserved