To 321gold home page

Home   Links   Editorials

Bull Markets Bullsh*t & Bubbles

Darryl Robert Schoon
Posted Jun 18, 2009

When credit growth is positive, bull markets result.
When credit growth is excessive, bubbles result.
When credit growth slows, recessions result
....and when credit growth contracts, all hell breaks loose.

In free markets, supply and demand determine price and profits. Capitalism's paper-based markets, however, are not free markets. In today's capitalist markets, price and profits are determined by credit flows emanating from government central banks.

Under capitalism - or more appropriately, under credit-based debtism - the supply and demand for credit is as important as the supply and demand for goods and services. The critical supply and demand dynamic that exists in free markets is distorted under capitalism, a distortion that will destroy capitalism just as communism was destroyed by a similar systemic distortion.

In credit-based capital markets, investors need credit like addicts need heroin; for just as addicts cannot survive without heroin, investors cannot profit without central bank credit. But more credit, like more heroin, becomes increasingly dangerous with continued usage.

It was the increased availability of credit in the 1980s that was responsible for the historic bull market from 1982 to 2007. In truth, the twenty-five year bull market was but a slow-building bubble in disguise, a bubble the Fed is now frantically trying to resuscitate in the hopes of preventing capitalism's imminent collapse.

Today, when it looks like a bull, walks like a bull and acts like a bull, it's probably a bubble.

Bubbles and busts have now replaced the expansions and contractions common to early stage capitalism. We are now in late-stage capitalism, where debt instead of credit is the critical factor and the bond markets, not equity markets, determine the economic future.

The serial and US real estate bubbles so distorted the global demand and supply dynamic that memories of the 1930s depression have now been re-awakened, memories that will soon become reality as deflation spreads around the world.

Deflation arises in the wake of extraordinary speculative bubbles and is caused by a collapse in demand which happens after such bubbles pop, when producers/sellers chase buyers hoping to turn inventories and soon-to-be illiquid assets into cash in order to pay down ever-compounding debts.

Deflation happened in the 1930s in the US, in the 1990s in Japan and is now again spreading in the US, the UK, Japan and other overly mature late-stage capitalist economies; and akin to a deadly economic cancer, deflation, once metastasized, is exceedingly difficult to eliminate.


In capitalist economies, constant credit fuels constant inflation which, in turn, results in constantly rising prices. This process was erroneously mistaken for wealth creation after the 1980s when inflation was contained to asset classes. But such asset gains are only temporary and become losses when speculative bubbles finally collapse.

Hoping to prevent a systemic deflationary collapse, central bankers flooded the US economy with credit in 2001, US central bankers slashing the Fed lending rate from 5.25 % down to 1 %. It was, however, a massive infusion of credit that only delayed and exacerbated the inevitable.

If you keep goosing the golden goose...

From 2002-2005, the Fed's 1% rates revived global demand but inadvertently created the US real estate bubble, the largest speculative bubble in history, a bubble underwritten by global investors who bought hundreds of billions of dollars of subprime mortgages that are now virtually worthless.

But the revival of demand was only temporary and the cure brought back the dreaded deflation that central bankers feared; and now, today, US rates are even lower, 0.25 %, but this time, low central bank rates will not have the desired effect. Lower rates will lead not to an increase in demand but to a depression.


When the US Fed cut rates in 2001, it gave rise to a massive bubble which drove global demand to new highs - which is what the Fed wanted. What the Fed didn't want is what happened next.

When the bubble collapsed, credit markets also collapsed when bondholders suddenly realized that their AAA rated subprime bonds were more subprime than AAA; and, when credit markets froze, the über-sophisticated Ponzi-scheme known as capitalism began to slow.

A constant expansion of credit is absolutely necessary for capitalism to function. Capitalism is like a Ponzi-scheme in that expansion is critical to its on-going survival. When capital markets slow, debt markets collapse as any slowdown in economic activity negatively impacts the ability of debtors to pay compounding debts.

The credit collapse in August 2007 is continuing despite the best efforts of governments and central banks to provide more credit to the markets. Such efforts are futile because banks and investors are increasingly reticent to loan when the odds of being repaid decrease as economic activity slows.


The road to hell is not a straight line and neither is the path towards the next deflationary depression. The recent stock market rally is a case in point. Hope springs eternal until it doesn't.

The recent stock market rebound is like a tan on a dying man.

The real conundrum faced by central bankers is how to convince investors that the economy is improving when it isn't. A slowing descent is not the same as ascending although many investors are willing to bet their last dollar that it might be so.

Hopelessness is an indicator that another Great Depression has arrived. The recent rally is an indicator that it is not yet here. When it does arrive, stock market rallies will be a memory of times past, times when it was believed that bubbles were real and that markets could be manipulated ad infinitum without consequence.

The easy part is over
The hard part's yet to be
The credit has been spent
And we have yet to see

What the reckoning will require
What bills are at our door
Will our children survive a future
That's been indebted by needless wars

The bankers are still in power
Politicians at their beck and call
The system's broke and bleeding
And night's about to fall

I dread tomorrow's awakening
What the light will show to be
A tomorrow spent and indebted
A wasted legacy

Buy gold, buy silver, have faith.


Darryl Robert Schoon
Schoon Archive

About Darryl Robert Schoon

In college, I majored in political science with a focus on East Asia (B.A. University of California at Davis, 1966). My in-depth study of economics did not occur until much later.

In the 1990s, I became curious about the Great Depression and in the course of my study, I realized that most of my preconceptions about money and the economy were just that - preconceptions. I, like most others, did not really understand the nature of money and the economy. Now, I have some insights and answers about these critical matters.

In October 2005, Marshall Thurber, a close friend from law school convened The Positive Deviant Network (the PDN), a group of individuals whom Marshall believed to be "out-of-the-box" thinkers and I was asked to join. The PDN became a major catalyst in my writings on economic issues.

When I discovered others in the PDN shared my concerns about the US economy, I began writing down my thoughts. In March 2007 I presented my findings to the Positive Deviant Network in the form of an in-depth 148-page analysis, "How to Survive the Crisis and Prosper In The Process."

The reception to my presentation, though controversial, generated a significant amount of interest; and in May 2007, "How To Survive The Crisis And Prosper In The Process" was made available at and I began writing articles on economic issues.

The interest in the book and my writings has been gratifying. During its first two months, was accessed by over 10,000 viewers from 93 countries. Clearly, we had struck a chord and, has been created to address this interest.

321gold Ltd