The double
edged sword of junior company financings
Dr Richard
Appel
December 29, 2003
After suffering
from a long, exhausting correction that ended in July, 2002,
the exploration stock sector staged an incredible price explosion.
The past several months witnessed the share prices of company
after company advancing 100%, 200%, 300% or even more. These
breathtaking, wealth-building increases created a euphoric condition
and quickly dispelled the frustration and despair that had earlier
consumed those that had invested in this tiny segment within
the universe of equity investments.
The earlier,
discouraging time frame began in June, 2002, when gold's new
Bull Market first rose to the $325 area. This occurred after
the yellow metal had ended its long, tedious and trying Bear
Market that had been in place since its $875 high in 1980. The
ensuing 20 year period saw the noble metal, after first plunging
into the low-$280 range, stage various rallies and declines until
its ultimate $252 low was posted in August, 1999. By June, 2002,
gold had arduously climbed a wall of questions, disbelief and
wonder until it had attacked an important milestone in the $325
range.
Despite the
junior gold market's initial expression of strength which accompanied
gold's climb from its Bear Market nadir, those who invested in
these companies were forced to withstand yet another period of
consternation. Investors were left wondering whether a new gold
Bull Market had truly arrived while they endured yet another
long, testing period when gold soared higher in price, and both
the juniors and even the major gold producers were left largely
behind. During the period between June, 2002 and July 2003, gold
trended higher and even briefly tested $390. While witnessing
the advances in gold, these steadfast gold share investors questioned
whether the junior gold exploration companies would ever again
exhibit renewed strength. In fact, as if to confirm their fears,
by early July, 2003, numerous exploration companies had actually
retreated to price ranges that approximated their earlier Bear
Market lows.
After enduring
this difficult period many investors were besides themselves
and wondered why both the major gold and their favorite junior
companies had not benefited from a rising gold price. Their quandary
was dispelled in July, 2003, but many of those who did not maintain
their confidence, their composure and their patience, were separated
from their share holdings only a fleeting moment before the inception
of the recent explosive price advances.
Beginning in
July, 2003, one by one, the junior explorers rose skyward out
of their depressed trading ranges. Company after company saw
their share prices rise 30% to 50% or more in a matter of a few
weeks. It was interesting for this observer how one could actually
witness the spreading, gradual wave of price increases.
As I stated
earlier, the past five months have been an incredible time for
the junior mineral exploration companies. This was a period when
the vast majority of notable companies soared from their earlier,
July nadirs. By early October, if a company reported exciting
news of an important acquisition, or exploration success, they
saw their shares double or even triple in price within a matter
of a few weeks. It was as though new life had been breathed into
the industry! However, after their rocketing stock prices quickly
made up for lost time, an important event occurred. It was the
influx of capital that was directed towards financing the various
companies. The money was to be used by the juniors in their quest
for mineral wealth and to the benefit of their shareholders.
An incredible
amount of money entered the funding pipeline for the junior companies.
The higher stock prices caused numerous funds and venture capitalists
to offer working capital to their favorite exploration or developing
enterprises. This, so that they too could participate in the
profits that they were confident, would be generated by future
junior successes.
When a small
company offers a financing they typically perform a unit offering.
A unit normally consists of one share plus one share purchase
warrant. For companies traded on the Toronto or Toronto Venture
Exchange, the share is fully paid and can normally be traded
after a mandatory four-month hold period. The warrant on the
other hand, gives the acquirer the right to purchase an additional
share at a fixed price within a given timeframe. This is typically
for one or two years. The price of the unit is usually set at
or below the current market price of the company's shares, and
the warrant is priced slightly higher.
For example,
if XYZ's stock is trading at $0.50 C. it may offer a unit at
$0.45 C. with the warrant at $0.55 C. with a one-year life. The
warrant acts as a sweetener to attract investment capital; it
offers the acquirer the added benefit of locking in the price
of the warrant share. In fact, in some cases it can double the
profit potential for the investor. In this example, if the price
of the stock rises to $1.00 C. the unit purchaser not only garners
a $0.55 C. profit from his share ($1.00 C. minus his $0.45 C.
cost), but also an additional $0.45 C. by exchanging his warrant
and $0.55 C. ($1.00 C. minus $0.55 C. cost). Thus, his initial
$0.45 C. investment will yield a total of $1.00 C. in profit
($0.55 C. plus $0.45 C.) if the stock merely advances to $1.00.
If it moves still higher in price during the one year life of
the warrant, it will benefit him to a greater amount.
How Can
the Influx of Junior Financings Influence the Overall Exploration
Market?
Under normal
circumstances a financing will only affect the issuing company.
This results from a series of events. First, when an equity offering
is announced those who participate may already be holders of
the company's stock. If this is the case, some of these individuals
will sell currently owned shares in order to pay for their financing
commitments. Later, if the warrants are in the money, they may
sell additional shares in the company, possibly from their then
free trading unit shares, in order to exercise them. Finally,
after spending additional capital to acquire the warrant shares,
they may sell some or all of these newly issued shares to lock
in their profit.
In each of
these instances stock of the company is sold into the market.
In the case of the newly tradable shares and warrant shares an
increase in the available supply of stock results, as well as
a dilution in the total issued and outstanding shares. All of
these conditions act to dampen price increases for the company.
Or, it may even foster a temporary lowering in the company's
share price.
The large number
of companies that have either closed or will soon close important
capital raising activities will be presented with both a blessing
and a potential curse. It has favored the companies with a generous
amount of working capital. This will allow them to advance their
favorite projects or to acquire additional ones. However, this
may occur at the expense of their stock prices when shares of
stock are sold to pay for the various financing stages described
above. Further, this potential problem is amplified by the combined
total number and amount of these equity financings.
I am not aware
of an accurate estimate of the total capital that has already
been committed to finance the Canadian junior companies during
the past several months. However, I would be surprised if it
is not already approaching $2 C. billion. This represents an
enormous amount of money dedicate to finding and making a mine
for these nascent companies. Further, it will result in an incredible
amount of new "paper" that is destined to one day enter
the market.
As I earlier
chronicled, due to a major financing a company's price may suffer
from the increased supply of its stock entering the market. If
you extend the ramifications of this effect from one individual
to that of several hundred companies, there will be a different
result. In this scenario we can have a plethora of funds and
venture capitalists selling positions in a widespread number
of companies, in order to either fund their financing commitments
or for profit-taking. This can place downward pressure upon a
large number of stocks, which in turn may spread to other companies
within this small market. The result may be to lower overall
prices for the entire market, and a major secondary correction.
A Major
Constant Of The Junior Exploration Sector
An important
recurring condition exists in the junior resource market that
all investors must understand, and for which they should be prepared.
When this market weakens those stocks that have waiting bids
typically find a great deal of their stock being offered. This
is due to the relatively illiquid nature of these small companies.
When this market corrects there are always individuals, funds
or others that will always require cash. They typically refrain
from initially selling their weaker stocks because they recognize
that they will force these shares lower and will sell little
stock in the process. They therefore search for those companies
with strong bids where they can sell stock with the least damaging
affect upon their share prices. If they possess a large position
and sell a small quantity of stock in a weakly bid company, they
will ultimately drive its share price lower and damage themselves
in the process.
If I am correct,
by February or March 2004, the vast majority of the new financings
will be free-trading. If the market is not flush with new buying
capital at that time we may suffer a period of decline across
the junior sector, as a stream of newly issued shares will becomes
available to enter the market.
I am addressing
this issue for two reasons. First, to help new investors better
understand the ramifications of junior company financing. Second,
I desire to make you aware of a potential short-term set-back
that it may generate. It may not occur, but the potential does
exist.
I continue
to believe that both gold and gold equities are in secular Bull
Markets. Further, I anticipate that they will last for several
more years. While the timing of the next major correction is
unknown it will likely appear when the current up-leg ends. It
may begin after gold posts a temporary peak, which I am confident
has not yet been seen. Or, for the juniors, it may be precipitated
if an insufficient amount of buying soon enters the market to
absorb the potential entrance of the newly free-trading financing
shares.
On a positive
cord, the great amount of capital that the juniors have been
able to raise will likely be rewarded by one or more major mineral
discoveries by this time next year. This will cause the share
price of the fortunate company to soar to multiples of its pre-discovery
level. Further, it will be taken by the entire exploration sector
as a confirmation of the reason why we have all become involved
in this industry. The rocketing stock price will generate great
excitement and share chasing, and will vindicate our belief that
fortunes can be made in this presently obscure market sector.
Additionally, it will act to attract a renewed and likely enormous
influx of capital into the market! Investors will be given tangible
evidence that this industry can indeed generate stock market
fortunes. This will enhance the share prices across the entire
industry. All stocks will again benefit from the newly injected
money inflow, and new record highs will punctuate the junior
stock tables.
The above was
excerpted from the January 2004 issue of Financial Insights ©
December 21, 2003.
Dr Richard
Appel
Financial
Insights
December 26, 2003
Financial Insights
is a monthly newsletter in which I discuss gold, the financial
markets, as well as various junior resource stocks that I believe
offer great price appreciation potential.
Please visit
my
website
where you will be able to view previous issues of Financial Insights,
as well as the companies that I am presently following. You will
also be able to learn about me and about a special subscription
offer.
CAVEAT
I expect to
have positions in many of the stocks that I discuss in these
letters, and I will always disclose them to you. In essence,
I will be putting my money where my mouth is! However, if this
troubles you please avoid those that I own! I will attempt wherever
possible, to offer stocks that I believe will allow my subscribers
to participate without unduly affecting the stock price. It is
my desire for my subscribers to purchase their stock as cheaply
as possible. I would also suggest to beginning purchasers of
these stocks, the following: always place limit orders when making
purchases. If you don't, you run the risk of paying too much
because you may inadvertently and unnecessarily raise the price.
It may take a little patience, but in the long run you will save
yourself a significant sum of money. In order to have a chance
for success in this market, you must spread your risk among several
companies. To that end, you should divide your available risk
money into equal increments. These are all specula-tions! Never
invest any money in these stocks that you could not afford to
lose all of.
Please call
the companies regularly. They are controlling your investments.
FINANCIAL INSIGHTS
is written and published by Dr. Richard Appel and is made available
for informational purposes only. Dr. Appel pledges to disclose
if he directly or indirectly has a position in any of the securities
mentioned. He will make every effort to obtain information from
sources believed to be reliable, but its accuracy and completeness
cannot be guaranteed. Dr. Appel encourages your letters and emails,
but cannot respond personally. Be assured that all letters will
be read and considered for response in future letters. It is
in your best interest to contact any company in which you consider
investing, regarding their financial statements and corporate
information. Further, you should thoroughly research and consult
with a professional investment advisor before making any equity
investments. Use of any information contained herein is at the
risk of the reader without responsibility on our part. Past performance
does not guarantee future results. © 2003 by Dr. Richard
S. Appel. All rights are reserved. Parts of this newsletter may
be reproduced in context, for inclusion in other publications
if the publisher's name and address are also included for credit.
_______________
321gold Inc
|